The rhetoric is pretty fierce these days, the election of Donald Trump has led to the United States revealing itself to be a racist, misogynist, transphobic hell hole well on the way to 21 st century fascism (cont pg 94 of Salon). The rest of the world looks at a place where the President seems to be throwing the occasional piece of red meat to his base while all enjoy the greatest physical comfort, liberty and freedom it’s ever been the privilege of a nation to suffer under. Clearly we need some form of test to decide between these two wildly divergent views of that reality outside the window. Fortunately today’s newspapers offer just such a test:
President Donald Trump said on Friday that National Football League (NFL) players who do not stand for the national anthem should be suspended for the season without pay.
Well, will they?
More importantly, will they because the President says they should?
There are places in the world where such obiter dicta by the bloke with all the guns and all the money would mean a screeching u-turn in public and social activity. A totalitarian state such as North Korea has been known – OK, we’ve reports of varying quality that – to execute those who diss the Leader’s merest musings. An authoritarian state could usefully be defined as one in which the Great Leader’s thoughts on football players become those of the league. A free country is one in which everyone thinks well, that’s an interesting thought Mr. President and then carries on to do whatever it was they desired in the first place.
Which gives us our test about America under that Trumpian bootheel, doesn’t it?
Is taking the knee going to mean a season’s suspension without pay because The Donald said so? If so then I agree, the United States is very much more authoritarian than any of us should be comfortable with. If not then we can leave Salon and its writers to their teenage fantasies, can’t we?
The language we use matters - it provides clarity to our own thoughts and enables…
It is now generally acknowledged that the structure of the NHS needs to be overhauled…
In the film Apollo 13, a loss of oxygen causes the crew to start inadvertently…
There's an idea out there which seems intuitive but then so many ideas do seem…
When we think about the darkly opaque goals of modern central bankers as they relate…
As the papers recently filled with the distressing images of desperate souls looking to escape…
View Comments
What will be the reaction if NFL teams take action on kneeling players as a response not to Trump but to declining custom?
Trump of course will be blamed by the media.
Trump's bet is that NFL fans are patriotic and don't like kneeling players, hence his stance will win him more support than he could hope to get from Salon readers.
The NFL Players' Association raised a grievance with the league that the policy on honoring the flag was reached without consultation with them required under the collective bargaining agreement. The NFL agreed to "suspend enforcement" of the rule for weeks and the NFLPA agreed not to litigate. This is what led to Trump reasserting his position in a tweet.
Trump has tweeted about how the NFL should behave, that companies should build factories in America not abroad, and that disorderly reporters ought to be jailed. None of these has the force of law, except at the Democratic National Committee, where either (A) individual liberty or (B) the continued existence of Trump, means that the absolutely worst outcome is certain, and moreover, each of its opponents wanted those bad outcomes.
By comparison, the campaign to require that everyone in the US receive at least $15 per hour, free medical care, and a free four-year sojourn at university, contemplates funding/enforcement at gunpoint.
As always, Trump's execution is poor. His unnecessary, renewed meddling again makes the anthem not just a protest against imaginary racism but a way for Democrat players to take a stand against him. But, as always, Trump's instincts are true. The NFL's customer base includes military families who demand respect for the flag regardless of the issue of the day, the NFL is foolish to let employees anger its customer base, and it is entirely proper for the President to encourage respect for the flag.