You What? (In Welsh)

From our Swindon correspondent:

From the BBC

£800m should be invested in public transport to help ease traffic jams on the M4, a report has recommended.

A commission was set up after Welsh ministers scrapped plans to build a £1.6bn relief road around Newport.

To encourage people out of their cars, its report suggested considering a “workplace parking levy” and ensuring public transport was “affordable for all”.

The panel was told not to consider plans for another motorway.

The M4 around Newport is the fourth most congested stretch of road in the UK.

I used to work around Cardiff and I sometime visit, and the problem is that the M4 is also the main local road from Newport to Cardiff. People on their way to Swansea get mixed up with local commuting traffic. The best solution is another road. Oh and “the M4 around Newport” is pretty crap, yes, but it’s only a couple of miles.
The problem with public transport is that Cardiff isn’t like London. It isn’t a donut with a load of offices in the centre surrounded by office workers. People work in and around the city. If you have trains into the centre, people then have to stop and change to get to their final destination, and by the time you’ve done all that hassle you might as well just sit in the traffic. If you want to go into the centre of Cardiff from Newport, or Bristol there’s already a cheap train.

And the other problem is that you’re about 9 months behind, laddies. There is no congestion at 8am around Newport at the moment. It’s blue all the way from Bristol to Cardiff. Everyone is working at home during Covid. What happens post-Covid? I don’t know but no-one is gagging to get back to the office every day now. So, put a pin in your choo-choos and see what the situation is like before spending a load of money, yeah?

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Tim Worstall

View Comments

  • So, put a pin in your choo-choos and see what the situation is like before spending a load of money, yeah?

    This eminently sensible message has failed to reach the ears of HS2, currently despoiling the River Misbourne outside Amersham.

    • The Department of Transport and the ORR produce figures saying that season ticket sales are falling, season ticket use is falling, peak crowding is falling. That's been happening for at least 3 years. But, we need to build a railway because of growth in demand?

      I think there's going to be seismic effects on rail post-Covid. Around half the trips are commuting and that means well over half the money. You lose 10-20% of that, things are going to get sticky. Government is going to have to prop up the rail operators until someone comes along with a Beeching 2 plan.

      • In my Train Operating Company we were told that season ticket sales paid all the costs of running the business and off peak / leisure fares were the profit.

  • I’ll go one further I’ve lived in Newport and worked in Cardiff. The geography means the road over a couple of miles goes from 4 to 2 lanes and back a number of times (bridges/overpasses/tunnels) and is also used locally as part of a ring road around Newport. The M4 also acts like another river through the city causing issues as there are limited crossing points and many are tied to busy junctions.
    The only practical solution is to build the suggested relief road around the other side of Newport. They did build a new road and bridge to allow you to cut around part of the centre of Newport that did make a difference, but only for local commuters and limited scope, when they shut the M4 (usually a couple of times a year for accidents) it acts as a bypass and is totally jammed

Share
Published by
Tim Worstall
Tags: cardifftrain

Recent Posts

The BBC and terrorism

The language we use matters - it provides clarity to our own thoughts and enables…

3 years ago

We Should Pay Medical Personnel For Each Procedure They Perform

It is now generally acknowledged that the structure of the NHS needs to be overhauled…

3 years ago

The Scrubbers Are Failing

In the film Apollo 13, a loss of oxygen causes the crew to start inadvertently…

3 years ago

Wondering whether an idea is actually correct or not

There's an idea out there which seems intuitive but then so many ideas do seem…

4 years ago

Is Cryptocurrency Our Revolution, Or Theirs?

When we think about the darkly opaque goals of modern central bankers as they relate…

4 years ago

Playing The Mischief With Us

As the papers recently filled with the distressing images of desperate souls looking to escape…

4 years ago