Realist, not conformist analysis of the latest financial, business and political news

Elinor Ostrom, Societal Organisation And The God Threshold

Elinor Ostrom gained the Nobel Prize in large part for explaining that there’s a method of societal organisation that isn’t markets and property rights as in capitalism and also isn’t regulation and control, as in a bureaucratic society. This finding of something called the God Threshold is working along the same lines.

So, Ostrom’s point. Garrett Hardin told us about the Tragedy of the Commons. If we’ve open, Marxist, access to a resource then fine. But if demand for the resource exceeds regenerative supply then that resource will become exhausted. For we’ve already said that, with open access, anyone who wants some can come and take it. Thus, in order for a resource to survive access must be limited. We can do this in one of two ways. We can parcel out private property, the capitalist – in Hardin’s description – way or we can have a bureaucracy, regulation, which limits access – the socialist way.

Ostrom pointed out that there’s a third way. For such resources do exist, demand is greater than supply, and yet they persist without either. That is, we can have self-regulating access to the resource among those concerned.

OK, excellent. But Ostrom’s system fails at groups larger than perhaps 2,000 to 3,000 people. So, we’re fine with say the limitation of access to a grazing commons – the steppes have been so regulated, interspersed with more than a little warfare, for millennia now. But climate change can’t be handled that way given how 7 billion of us contribute to the problem.

OK. At which point we get this:

[perfectpullquote align=”full” bordertop=”false” cite=”” link=”” color=”” class=”” size=””] The God threshold: why societies don’t need a moral deity until they hit one million Human societies hit a ‘God threshold’ at around one million people where they need a moralising, rule-making deity to keep order, a new study suggests. Previously it was thought that the expansion of complex societies went hand-in-hand with controlling religions, which installed principles of right and wrong and allowed large numbers to live together peacefully. But a new study by Oxford University and Keio University in Japan, found that only ‘megasocieties’ of more than one million require the kind of unyielding cohesive beliefs that gave rise to major religions like Christianity, Judaism, Islam or Buddhism. [/perfectpullquote]

The similarity is, of course, that certain ways of regulating a human society work up to a certain size of that human society. Above that methods need to change. We prove this the same way Ostrom did too. Those societies that didn’t develop such a management system didn’t survive, those that did are with us still.

Of course, this won’t aid nor please those who really believe, that it’s all only a management system, not a revelation, but then reality isn’t there to please us, is it?

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jonathan Harston
Jonathan Harston
2 years ago

When I went brambling as a child there were always others doing so, and I would only get about one tub or so. Now I go brambling and i’m the only one there, and I come home with buckets and buckets full. I often still have the freezer full of the damn things the next spring.

Andrew Carey
Andrew Carey
2 years ago

Twice last year I picked a kilo of blackberries in 20 minutes. All gone now, used up in porridge, pies. But I think we’re outliers Jonathan. People are richer and want stuff of higher value and quality.
Like dandelion leaves of a generation earlier which can be washed, steamed and put in salads, nobody would do it now because lettuce is easier and better.
You should try the commercially grown blackberries sometime, and the liqueurs that include blackberries.

Quentin Vole
Quentin Vole
2 years ago
Reply to  Andrew Carey

I remember (1960s) picking nettles for nettle soup and as a vegetable supplement for stews. You need to pick young, green ones, whose leaves taste (and cook) a bit like spinach.

Commercial blackberries have less taste than (the best) wild brambles.

Dodgy Geezer
Dodgy Geezer
2 years ago

“..But if demand for the resource exceeds regenerative supply then that resource will become exhausted….” Well, up to a point, Lord Copper. That Malthusian argument sounds so simple and obvious, that it can easily divert you from the fact that ‘resources’ never actually seem to run out. Never, in the history of the world – even though demand has been exceeded many times. Julian Simon first pointed this out. When demand exceeds supply a lot of ancillary pressures come into play. People start recycling, looking for new sources of supply, looking for more efficient ways to use what they have,… Read more »

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x