A Linguistic Complaint About Eddie Izzard

9
1112

This annoys:

Eddie Izzard has adopted the pronouns “she” and “her”, saying she wants “to be based in girl mode from now on”.

The actor and comedian made the announcement during an appearance on the Sky Arts series Portrait Artist Of The Year last week in which she described herself as gender-fluid, prompting the LGBT charity Stonewall to praise her for her bravery.

Leave the bravery part to one side. It’s this contention that she and her are being adopted as pronouns that annoys. They’re not. I and me are still in use by Izzard to describe the self. So, the pronouns adopted by Izzard are I and me as with all the rest of us.

The contention actually is that the rest of use are being told to adopt she and her as the pronouns we use to describe Izzard. That is, we must adopt the pronouns, Izzard isn’t.

Now, perhaps we will be polite and do so and perhaps we won’t. That’s up to each one of us. Personally can’t see any reason not to be polite except in those instances – you know, the gentleman thing of only insulting when insult is meant – where not being polite is the point.

But it does indeed grate to be told something so obviously linguistically untrue. Izzard hasn’t adopted the pronouns she and her. The insistence is that we must.

You know, she and her are third person things, not ones that are relevant to first person language?

9
Leave a Reply

avatar
8 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
9 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
9 Comment authors
MrKingjghBarksFredLeo Savantt Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
aaa
Guest
aaa

We’re told we must do this because “it’s polite”. How is it polite to demand that millions of people around the world adjust all of their memories and rewire their understanding of the world on Eddie Izzard’s say-so?

Boganboy
Guest
Boganboy

It’s not. I’d argue that all people who insist on this nonsense should be called ‘it’. If you can be bothered to remember who they are, that is.

FrankH
Guest
FrankH

What he really means is that his pronouns are “ME, ME, ME”.

John B
Guest
John B

Yes but the mentally ill refer to themselves in the third person – it’s one of the early clinical signs.

Leo Savantt
Guest
Leo Savantt

Polite be dammed, Izzard is a bloke, end of.

Les flippantly, this sort of demand genuinely undermines what it is to be a woman, its misogynistic, detached from reality and narcissistic, personally I won’t kowtow in the name of politeness, because it is an insult to women and therefore exceedingly uncivil.

Fred
Guest
Fred

Eddie Izzard seems to be a twat that doesn’t have a twat, if you will permit me to be so rude.

Barks
Guest
Barks

Why cater to these nutcases? Ignoring them is the best policy.

jgh
Guest
jgh

Maybe Eddie Izzard really does refer to Eddie Izzard in the third person. Ooo, I’ve discovered a new word: illeism.

MrKing
Guest
MrKing

I’ll use the pronouns Twat and Wanker to refer to Izzard from now on. Actually quite easy as I’ve used them for ages anyway.