Realist, not conformist analysis of the latest financial, business and political news

Meaning Nothing – Ireland To Entirely Divest From Fossil Fuels

Ireland has proudly announced that it is the first country to entirely – no, totally – divest from fossil fuels. This means rather less than nothing, as it doesn’t actually mean that Ireland won’t be using any fossil fuels. It just means that the State itself, the funds it controls, won’t be buying shares in fossil fuel companies. Not buying Shell or BP stock is not a great blow against climate change:

Ireland is set to become the first country to stop public investments in fossil fuels.

The Fossil Fuel Divestment bill was passed by the lower house of parliament, Dáil Éireann, on Thursday.

The bill is expected to pass relatively quickly through the Seanad (senate), and will force the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund to end any investments in non-renewable energy in five years.

Environment activists have welcomed the news.

It’s feel good trivia rather than anything important.

The text of the bill calls for the complete divestment of the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund of fossil fuel companies within five years from the commencement of the bill’s approval. The aim, as expressed in the bill, is “to precipitate a timely decarbonisation process in line with Ireland’s climate change commitments under Article 2 of the Paris Agreement.”

Not buying shares and not using fossil fuels are two rather different things. Owning or not owning Exxon stock makes no difference whatsoever to which fuel people top up with at the petrol station now, does it?

Ireland has lagged behind other European countries in cutting emissions and Irish households emit 60 per cent more carbon than the average EU home, in part because of the use of peat and coal for heating, according to a government study.

“We have had a very carbon-based economy and society for a number of years, so this is a huge change for us, but it has to happen,” said Thomas Pringle, the independent parliamentarian who sponsored the legislation.

“The bill sends a very clear message . . . that the Irish government sees the transition away from fossil fuels as very important,” he added.

The difference this will make to the use of peat and coal is precisely nothing, isn’t it? Unlike, say, that digging up of County Down* going on to put natural gas pipelines in. You know, investing in fossil fuels so as to reduce carbon emissions?

The full bill is here. Signifies nothing, just wind.

*Yes, I know, different country.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
5 years ago

Sure it signifies something- that the Irish have chosen to make themselves poorer.

Chester Draws
Chester Draws
5 years ago

Excellent. Every time a person divests it make me buying shares in those companies cheaper.

If they’d just like to work out that all the airlines, transport companies and car manufacturers are complicit in fossil fuel usage then I’ll be able to buy them cheaper too.

(Note, I invest for dividends not capital gain. If every share fell in price it would suit me just fine.)

5 years ago
Reply to  Chester Draws

I’m in too. Most people in the stock market are looking for value and not trying to impress their Twitter base. In fact, there are so many of us that Ireland’s showy “divestment” will not alter the price of any stock issue. Ireland will be replaced as a ExxonMobil’s shareholder with owners who don’t care to posture about not being owners. But a fall in share price doesn’t suit me, nor am I happy milking the cow and never calling the veterinarian. Preservation of capital, so you have the option of bailing out, is vital, capitalists care about it, and… Read more »

5 years ago

Why is Ireland engaging in Strategic Investment in the first place? Investment is when you place your capital in the hands of people with a better plan for it, expecting to have more capital later. This fund is Ireland stealing capital and using it to make an ideological point about which investments they are too swell to make. New Hampshire has a Rainy Day Fund, a supposed surplus, though not a real surplus, as the lack of wealth to pay bureaucrats the entire pension they have been promised is a much larger deficit. Arguments that every $1 to tide the… Read more »

Rhoda Klapp
Rhoda Klapp
5 years ago

So, in the event of a massive oil find in Irish territorial waters they won’t want to tax it?

Do they in fact issue exploration leases?

5 years ago
Reply to  Rhoda Klapp

That massive find of whale oil has already been made, roughly at the same time the beef was hooked.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x