It really does take a certain form of blindness to complain about the very process which solves your identified problem. Yet this is what Felicity Lawrence manages with her bemoaning of the effects of Brexit upon food supply and the labour force in it. Brexit is going to mean, unless something is done, that the foreign and low paid pickers won’t be coming over here. OK, that’s certainly a possible outcome. She also mentions that in order to get Honest Brits out into the fields they have to be treated better. Better paid, offered more certain hours and so on. OK. Therefore something has to be done to make conditions in the fields better. But then that’s exactly what Brexit is going to do, isn’t it?

To miss this is odd because it’s an entirely Marxist point to make:

The Mackeys have the equivalent of nine full-time staff, made up of 13 to 14 people who work varying patterns that suit them. They are paid the London living wage like Brown’s packers. In good years, workers are also paid a share of the profits in bonuses. Unlike many agency workers supplied to industrial farms to harvest and pack, the workers on Ripple Farm receive holiday pay, sick pay and good protective clothing to keep them warm and dry.

Absolutely super, who doesn’t want the workers to have good lives?

This is not how most food businesses work today. Large numbers of them have depended on EU migrants – around 98% of seasonal workers in primary agriculture are foreign-born and 33% of workers in food manufacturing are migrants.

OK, it’s that second part that will be solved by the Brexit being so decried. Because, as any good Marxists should know, we’ll be getting rid of that reserve army of the unemployed. As Marx did point out, where there’s a shortage of labour the employer – the capitalist – has to share rising productivity with the workers. For he’s in competition with the other capitalists for the profits that can be made from the exploitation. This does not happen where there are the unemployed. Why bother to improve the conditions of the workforce when you can just hire more starvelings at will?

That is, cutting off that access to the starvelings of Europe means that farmers will all have to improve labour conditions in order to get the labour whose faces they can grind into the dust.

Now, we don’t think that’s all that good an idea, we’re just fine with labour coming over here to do the labour we don’t want to do. But within Felicity’s world of concerns it is still true that she’s complaining about the very thing which solves her concern. Which is pretty good really, when you think about it. It’s also Very Guardian.

5
Leave a Reply

avatar
5 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
Fred ZJerryCSteveDiogenes Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Diogenes
Guest
Diogenes

I find it odd that before Brexit, the Graun sympathised with the migrant pickers for working long hours for low pay in poor conditions and now they regret their absence

Diogenes
Guest
Diogenes

And sympathise with the farmers who might have to raise wages

Steve
Guest
Steve

I wonder how much cheap migrant labour retards the adoption of new technology.

Less point in investing in funky new machinery when you can hire a busload of Miroslavs for buttons and put them up in tents.

JerryC
Guest
JerryC

Immigration enthusiasts love the “crops rotting in the fields” scare stories, and I assume they’re effective because the same stories keep getting recycled over and over. Something about food going to waste triggers an emotional response in people, like your mom telling you to finish your peas because of the starving kids in Africa. It’s like the ancestral memory of food scarcity makes that sort of thing resonate on a subconscious level.

Fred Z
Guest
Fred Z

On the other hand, if Brit farmers are forced by a labour shortage to raise wages and then prices, maybe consumers will buy the stuff that Miroslav now grows at home. Then farmers will quit, sell their land and at long last the UK housing shortage will be solved.

Hurray for Brexit and Miroslav, who ain’t going to stop working and producing stuff.